To say that it was a parody is too true, it's like the whole thing but in an alternate story line, where hedgehogs (?) ruled the world, and suddenly some kind of a prophecy (??) surrounding them. And sonic has an annoying sister. Sounds worse than Amy, honestly.
Toggle shoutbox
Shoutbox
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Which Sonic Show Do You Like The Least?
Started by
, Jun 25 2008 06:45 PM
42 replies to this topic
#22
DCC
-
- Fellow FUSer
-
- 239 posts
Fellow FUSer
Posted 04 July 2008 - 03:46 AM
I would have to say "Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog" was my least favorite, by default. I haven't taken the time to watch any of the others and at the time "Sonic Underground" and "Sonic X" came out I was still upset about Sonic Sat a.m. being canceled (but I over it now). It sounds like the others, especially "Sonic X" would be a waste of my time. I felt the art of AoStH was awful(especially the backgrounds), and the stories could get too goofy. Although AoStH did have its good points, there were some funny moments and the friendship between Sonic and Tails provided some heart to the series.
#23
salamander
-
- Sea3on Consultant
- 425 posts
You can do whatever you want in life.
- Gender:Female
- Location:calgary, canada
Posted 04 July 2008 - 01:10 PM
For awhile I really hated AOSTH just because it wasn't Satam. The two always got mixed up, so when I finally clued into Satam and tried to catch it on TV, they were always airing AOSTH instead. Now that I've got my Satam fix I can like AOSTH again. They're polar opposites, but AOSTH is great in a silly slapdash way. I always loved Scratch and Grounder, and the WTF-ness of Sonic Says (most of them are on youtube, they're hilarious).
Sonic Underground grew on me, even though it had some stupid decisions behind it, like the songs, character designs, or having Sonia voiced by Urkel. It had some nice stories, I liked Sonia and Manic, and Bartleby was close enough to Antoine to get my attention. (I swear I would love Satan himself if he had a uniform and a bad french accent)
I bought Sonic the Movie, watched it once and then forgot about it. There are a couple points I remember liking, such as Sera playing games with Eggman, Tails being afraid of lightning, Knuckles' hat and Metal Sonic. I can't remember if Metal Sonic's death scene was kept in the dub or not, but it was pretty well done.
I've never seen Sonic X actually. I was never really interested in the whole Sonic Adventure universe, even though there were cute characters like Rouge and Cream. Shadow was just boring IMHO. It's certainly the prettiest looking but I just can't seem to care enough to watch it.
So I uh.. don't have a vote I guess. I like bits and pieces of the ones I've seen, with AoSth being my favorite, and obviously I love Satam more than all of them put together.
Sonic Underground grew on me, even though it had some stupid decisions behind it, like the songs, character designs, or having Sonia voiced by Urkel. It had some nice stories, I liked Sonia and Manic, and Bartleby was close enough to Antoine to get my attention. (I swear I would love Satan himself if he had a uniform and a bad french accent)
I bought Sonic the Movie, watched it once and then forgot about it. There are a couple points I remember liking, such as Sera playing games with Eggman, Tails being afraid of lightning, Knuckles' hat and Metal Sonic. I can't remember if Metal Sonic's death scene was kept in the dub or not, but it was pretty well done.
I've never seen Sonic X actually. I was never really interested in the whole Sonic Adventure universe, even though there were cute characters like Rouge and Cream. Shadow was just boring IMHO. It's certainly the prettiest looking but I just can't seem to care enough to watch it.
So I uh.. don't have a vote I guess. I like bits and pieces of the ones I've seen, with AoSth being my favorite, and obviously I love Satam more than all of them put together.
#24
Guest_Talonfire_*
Guest_Talonfire_*
-
- GUESTS
Posted 09 July 2008 - 06:20 PM
Sonic X by far. Say what you like about Sonic Underground, but I didn't think it was that bad. Despite the often bad songs, Sonic Underground stayed true to the nature versus machines, and freedom theme that Sonic was originally about... Sonic X didn't do that.
Why I consider Sonic X the worst, well it was just really dry. Unlike DiC's Sonic cartoons, Sonic X didn't pull me in... I forced myself to watch every episode just to say I did, and eventually it just became background noise while I was doing more important things. Some fans argue that the Metarex story arc was an improvement, but in my opinion it was even worse. Sonic in space fighting giant mech aliens... okay am I the only one that sees something wrong with this picture? At least the first two seasons, as dull as they were, were usually classic Sonic versus Doctor Robot- I'm sorry, "Eggman" and thus had some relevance to Sonic's origins. As for Chris, I didn't find him as annoying as some people, though; I did feel that Sonic didn't get enough screen time. Sonic usually popped up at the last minute to save the day, so the show felt less about him, and more about the rest of the cast since he spent most of his time taking naps in trees.
Sonic X had a lot of potential, but it ended up being the combined essence of everything that's wrong with Sonic today in my humble opinion. Maybe I just don't appreciate SegaSonic since SatAM and Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog are what got me into the games in the first place, but regardless Sonic X just didn't do it for me.
Why I consider Sonic X the worst, well it was just really dry. Unlike DiC's Sonic cartoons, Sonic X didn't pull me in... I forced myself to watch every episode just to say I did, and eventually it just became background noise while I was doing more important things. Some fans argue that the Metarex story arc was an improvement, but in my opinion it was even worse. Sonic in space fighting giant mech aliens... okay am I the only one that sees something wrong with this picture? At least the first two seasons, as dull as they were, were usually classic Sonic versus Doctor Robot- I'm sorry, "Eggman" and thus had some relevance to Sonic's origins. As for Chris, I didn't find him as annoying as some people, though; I did feel that Sonic didn't get enough screen time. Sonic usually popped up at the last minute to save the day, so the show felt less about him, and more about the rest of the cast since he spent most of his time taking naps in trees.
Sonic X had a lot of potential, but it ended up being the combined essence of everything that's wrong with Sonic today in my humble opinion. Maybe I just don't appreciate SegaSonic since SatAM and Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog are what got me into the games in the first place, but regardless Sonic X just didn't do it for me.
#27
DerekHedgehog87
-
- Fellow FUSer
-
- 131 posts
Fellow FUSer
- Gender:Male
- Location:The Great Unknown in Indiana
Posted 17 July 2008 - 08:22 AM
My reviews:
Sonic X: Sure I enjoyed it because it was a Sonic cartoon. However even though it lasted longer than all the other cartoons, the last season kinda repeated the events of Sonic NextGen (kinda) by introducing new characters that were completely unnecessary.
The Good: Sonic the Hedgehog, Shadow the Hedgehog, good graphics
The Bad: Chris Thorndyke, Meterax, bad voice-acting, terrible plots, current characters, Amy Rose
Rating:
Sonic the Movie: First time I saw Sonic as an anime. Wasn't impressed but at least there were a couple SatAM stuff, like the name Robotnik (instead of Eggman) & Robotropolis. Voice-acting wasn't good & some characters were annoying. But at least Tails & Knuckles are in it at the same time. Plus fans loved Metal Sonic & Metal Sonic makes a very good villain.
The Good: Sonic, Tails, Knuckles, & Metal Sonic. Good storyline.
The Bad: the Princess. Robotnik constantly flirting with her. Bad voice-acting.
Rating:
Sonic Underground: Didn't like what I saw the first time but at least there were a ton of SatAM stuff compared to any other cartoon. Jaleel White returns yet again as Sonic while voicing Sonic's other siblings. Also this is the final time we get to see classic Sonic before his redesign & where he started to be in his current situation. Also this is the last known American-made Sonic cartoon (even though it was made in France) before Sega of Japan took complete control of Sonic & really started making him worse than ever. The bad news is there are no other Freedom Fighters. But the good news is Knuckles finally makes an appearance. The singing is kinda unnecessary though. Sonic already sang a few times with his guitar in SatAM.
The Good: Jaleel White as Sonic, Knuckles, classic SatAM references still alive at this point.
The Bad: No other Freedom Fighters, Robotnik's new henchmen, Sonic a Prince & has siblings?! (since when??!!)
Rating: {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_surprised.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_surprised.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif
Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog: The very first Sonic cartoon (unless SatAM was the first?) & it had all of the humor of the classic cartoons like Bugs Bunny & Scooby-Doo. Plus the voice-acting was excellent. Though Robotnik was very silly, he still wouldn't give up which makes the show even funnier. Scratch & Grounder (they later would do the voice of Knuckles & Robotnik in Underground) add even more humor as the "very stupid but very persistent" robots. Plus at the end of each episode, there is a "Sonic Sez" segment about life lessons & telling kids what to do & what not to do in real life.
The Good: Jaleel White as Sonic, Tails, classic humor.
The Bad: plots are not as understandable, no references to games, no Power Rings?
Rating: {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_surprised.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif
Sonic the Hedgehog/Sonic SatAM: A cartoon that is severely underrated by many critics but loved by many fans & no doubt the best Sonic cartoon ever made, SatAM has a darker, more developed storyline & has characters that we all can relate to. Sure we're not perfect (like Antoine) but we all have our faults. Anyway Sonic SatAM takes place on Mobius where Robotnik controls the planet with an iron fist, roboticizing any Mobian he captures. However there are a group of Mobians called Freedom Fighters who stand in his way. One of them is the great Sonic the Hedgehog. Of course there are Tails, Sally, Bunnie, Antoine, & Rotor. Sally is the brains of the group, actually planning out missions that are somewhat successful (despite her getting criticism for being "nude" even though she isn't thanks to the fur). Tails, the young two-tailed fox who is Sonic's best bud. Rotor, the mechanic who is a good inventor (no reason given on his appearance change even though his appearance was fine in Season 1). Antoine, the goofball who tries too hard to prove he is the real deal mostly to Sally, only for his plans to backfire. Bunnie, the half-roboticized but very lovable Southerner who is the strongest & fights with Kung Fu. Snively is RoButtnik's assistant & Robotnik is the villain. The plots are outstanding & the show is addicting. The BEST thing that happened to Sonic to date.
The Good: Everything.
The Bad: Some slow, boring parts, but very small & short. Antoine pretty much acting like an idiot at the WORST time.
Rating: {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/het.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/het.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/het.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/het.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/het.gif
Sonic X: Sure I enjoyed it because it was a Sonic cartoon. However even though it lasted longer than all the other cartoons, the last season kinda repeated the events of Sonic NextGen (kinda) by introducing new characters that were completely unnecessary.
The Good: Sonic the Hedgehog, Shadow the Hedgehog, good graphics
The Bad: Chris Thorndyke, Meterax, bad voice-acting, terrible plots, current characters, Amy Rose
Rating:
Sonic the Movie: First time I saw Sonic as an anime. Wasn't impressed but at least there were a couple SatAM stuff, like the name Robotnik (instead of Eggman) & Robotropolis. Voice-acting wasn't good & some characters were annoying. But at least Tails & Knuckles are in it at the same time. Plus fans loved Metal Sonic & Metal Sonic makes a very good villain.
The Good: Sonic, Tails, Knuckles, & Metal Sonic. Good storyline.
The Bad: the Princess. Robotnik constantly flirting with her. Bad voice-acting.
Rating:
Sonic Underground: Didn't like what I saw the first time but at least there were a ton of SatAM stuff compared to any other cartoon. Jaleel White returns yet again as Sonic while voicing Sonic's other siblings. Also this is the final time we get to see classic Sonic before his redesign & where he started to be in his current situation. Also this is the last known American-made Sonic cartoon (even though it was made in France) before Sega of Japan took complete control of Sonic & really started making him worse than ever. The bad news is there are no other Freedom Fighters. But the good news is Knuckles finally makes an appearance. The singing is kinda unnecessary though. Sonic already sang a few times with his guitar in SatAM.
The Good: Jaleel White as Sonic, Knuckles, classic SatAM references still alive at this point.
The Bad: No other Freedom Fighters, Robotnik's new henchmen, Sonic a Prince & has siblings?! (since when??!!)
Rating: {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_surprised.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_surprised.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif
Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog: The very first Sonic cartoon (unless SatAM was the first?) & it had all of the humor of the classic cartoons like Bugs Bunny & Scooby-Doo. Plus the voice-acting was excellent. Though Robotnik was very silly, he still wouldn't give up which makes the show even funnier. Scratch & Grounder (they later would do the voice of Knuckles & Robotnik in Underground) add even more humor as the "very stupid but very persistent" robots. Plus at the end of each episode, there is a "Sonic Sez" segment about life lessons & telling kids what to do & what not to do in real life.
The Good: Jaleel White as Sonic, Tails, classic humor.
The Bad: plots are not as understandable, no references to games, no Power Rings?
Rating: {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_surprised.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif
Sonic the Hedgehog/Sonic SatAM: A cartoon that is severely underrated by many critics but loved by many fans & no doubt the best Sonic cartoon ever made, SatAM has a darker, more developed storyline & has characters that we all can relate to. Sure we're not perfect (like Antoine) but we all have our faults. Anyway Sonic SatAM takes place on Mobius where Robotnik controls the planet with an iron fist, roboticizing any Mobian he captures. However there are a group of Mobians called Freedom Fighters who stand in his way. One of them is the great Sonic the Hedgehog. Of course there are Tails, Sally, Bunnie, Antoine, & Rotor. Sally is the brains of the group, actually planning out missions that are somewhat successful (despite her getting criticism for being "nude" even though she isn't thanks to the fur). Tails, the young two-tailed fox who is Sonic's best bud. Rotor, the mechanic who is a good inventor (no reason given on his appearance change even though his appearance was fine in Season 1). Antoine, the goofball who tries too hard to prove he is the real deal mostly to Sally, only for his plans to backfire. Bunnie, the half-roboticized but very lovable Southerner who is the strongest & fights with Kung Fu. Snively is RoButtnik's assistant & Robotnik is the villain. The plots are outstanding & the show is addicting. The BEST thing that happened to Sonic to date.
The Good: Everything.
The Bad: Some slow, boring parts, but very small & short. Antoine pretty much acting like an idiot at the WORST time.
Rating: {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_e_biggrin.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/het.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/het.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/het.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/het.gif {SMILIES_PATH}/het.gif
Don't you ever mess with the hedgehog.
#28
-
- GUESTS
Posted 17 July 2008 - 03:39 PM
Sonic X, though I prefer the last season to AOSTH, it suffered from the same thing that plagues recent Sonic games. New characters are always showing up taking major roles from established characters. Heck even the president seemed like more of a major player then good ol’ Tails. As classic as the first season was, Sonic and friends versus Eggman it got boring and predictable. Why couldn’t the doctor hold some of the aces some of the time?
AOSTH, the show didn’t go anywhere but, pure comedy doesn’t have to go anywhere. Good humor came from every one, Blundering robot lackeys, the Doctor’s plans and inventions that range from classic freeze ray to the bizarre. It’s not that I don’t like this show I was enjoy the other two more.
Sonic Underground, It started out with the same premise as SATam but, took a major turn. I really liked the plots but None of them went anywhere! Deroboticiser hoax, Sonic concurs water, gone the next episode. Dingo monster turned back into lackey (didn’t Robotnik say countless times that arc he’d roboticise him)? On the plus side Knuckles cartoon debut and he came back for three more episodes to.
Sonic the Movie, I loved the fact it had a major “what if factor”, and took things from the games and things from seemingly no where. If it had become a series I would’ve looked forward to it expanding on subplots like the post apocalypse Earth Robotnik is from. The wreckage Sonic lives in. Why does Tails have a permanent cold? The voice acting wasn’t all that great that being the only short coming for me. I would of also looked forward so learning more of planet Freedom’s geography.
AOSTH, the show didn’t go anywhere but, pure comedy doesn’t have to go anywhere. Good humor came from every one, Blundering robot lackeys, the Doctor’s plans and inventions that range from classic freeze ray to the bizarre. It’s not that I don’t like this show I was enjoy the other two more.
Sonic Underground, It started out with the same premise as SATam but, took a major turn. I really liked the plots but None of them went anywhere! Deroboticiser hoax, Sonic concurs water, gone the next episode. Dingo monster turned back into lackey (didn’t Robotnik say countless times that arc he’d roboticise him)? On the plus side Knuckles cartoon debut and he came back for three more episodes to.
Sonic the Movie, I loved the fact it had a major “what if factor”, and took things from the games and things from seemingly no where. If it had become a series I would’ve looked forward to it expanding on subplots like the post apocalypse Earth Robotnik is from. The wreckage Sonic lives in. Why does Tails have a permanent cold? The voice acting wasn’t all that great that being the only short coming for me. I would of also looked forward so learning more of planet Freedom’s geography.
#29
Guest_Biohazard_*
Guest_Biohazard_*
-
- GUESTS
Posted 21 July 2008 - 08:35 AM
Sonic Underground.
Damnable Frenchman! [/xenophobia!]
Damnable Frenchman! [/xenophobia!]
#30
Guest_ChadtheCartoonNut_*
Guest_ChadtheCartoonNut_*
-
- GUESTS
Posted 21 July 2008 - 08:56 AM
Sonic X is it's name!
Boring the hell out of Chad is it's game!!
Boring the hell out of Chad is it's game!!
#31
Speedy_25
-
- Fellow FUSer
-
- 680 posts
SatAM Vet. (knew the show since it first came out)
- Gender:Male
- Location:Portland, OR
Posted 21 July 2008 - 11:15 PM
my most hated Sonic show, will always be Sonic X
My number one reason why: Chris F*CKING Thorndyke, oh, and of course Amy
My number one reason why: Chris F*CKING Thorndyke, oh, and of course Amy
#32
Guest_Telgin_*
Guest_Telgin_*
-
- GUESTS
Posted 22 July 2008 - 05:23 PM
I can't decide between the movie, Sonic X or SU, considering I haven't seen any of them. I strongly suspect that I would like them less than Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog.
I would probably like SU or Sonic X least. Sonic X has the annoying SoJ storylines and characters, but SU has a perverted version of Robotnik with Optimus Prime's voice actor and singing. Hard decision there. The movie probably isn't that bad.
I would probably like SU or Sonic X least. Sonic X has the annoying SoJ storylines and characters, but SU has a perverted version of Robotnik with Optimus Prime's voice actor and singing. Hard decision there. The movie probably isn't that bad.
#33
-
- GUESTS
Posted 30 July 2008 - 04:08 PM
SatAm is OK, but it would be better if it had Amy, SonX Eggman,no Knothole,but the FF's still there.
My rating 4 SatAm: 87%/100
That's good enough right,?
SU=1%/100
SonX= 99%/100
OVA=20%100
AoSth=64%/100
My rating 4 SatAm: 87%/100
That's good enough right,?
SU=1%/100
SonX= 99%/100
OVA=20%100
AoSth=64%/100
#34
furrykef
-
- Tech Guy
- 3,983 posts
Fellow FUSer
- Gender:Male
Posted 30 July 2008 - 06:29 PM
I can't imagine your opinions being very popular around here, N64fan.
#35
-
- GUESTS
Posted 01 August 2008 - 11:28 AM
I know, everyone here hates SonX...
But you can think what ya want, 'cause I live in the USA!
But you can think what ya want, 'cause I live in the USA!
#36
Guest_Talonfire_*
Guest_Talonfire_*
-
- GUESTS
Posted 01 August 2008 - 12:44 PM
QUOTE ("N64fan":26amefbx)
I know, everyone here hates SonX...
But you can think what ya want, 'cause I live in the USA!
But you can think what ya want, 'cause I live in the USA!
I can't speak for everyone here, but I don't hate Sonic X. I forced myself to watch its entire run (the 4Kids dub mind you) and I found it to be an average anime. Thinking something is mediocre, and hating it are two different things. Now I'm not a huge fan of anime, so this effects my standing with Sonic X significantly. Everything about X screamed run of the mill, Sonic's generic hero personality, Robot- Eggman being a comic relief idiot of a villain, a bunch of unnecessary melodrama with Chris, dry storylines and story arcs, etc.
For me it's really a matter of quality. Essentially Sonic X was Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog for the modern generation, silly slapstick with some serious elements thrown into it to appeal to modern trends. While I bought Shout Factory's Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog volume one, and will buy the next two I will honestly say that AoStH is not something that the whole family can enjoy. It's intended purely for the younger crowd, and the only reason I'm buying the DVD sets for this particular series is the nostalgia value. Sonic X falls into the same boat, the younger Sonic fans like it and grew up with it, and they'll likely buy the DVDs for nostalgia, but the adults of the family probably won't enjoy it.
Sonic the Hedgehog (SatAM) and Sonic Underground were quality stories that the entire family could enjoy. Both series' were first and foremost, "serious" and contained quite a few dark themes to appeal to an older audience, but they also had their fair share of humor and very rarely did they go overboard with it. There were a couple times in both series' where traditional slapstick was applied, in SatAM this usually involved Antoine (particularly the Antoine shorts in season two), and in Sonic Underground Sleet and Dingo occasionally ended up in a slapstick situation, but it wasn't something that happened every episode. Both of these series' can appeal to both children and adults because of their content.
#37
Guest_MauEvig_*
Guest_MauEvig_*
-
- GUESTS
Posted 09 August 2008 - 05:38 PM
There isn't a Sonic show I absolutely hate. SatAM was the best story wise and graphic wise, but all of the Sonic shows had their good and bad points.
Here's how I see it.
Sonic X: Too many humans. Other than that I didn't see enough of it to get a good grasp of it.
Sonic Underground: The Singing, Jaleel White doing Sonia's voice (Sonic and Manic's voice are good and all, but their sister too? O.o; ) and no Tails. What's a Sonic cartoon without Tails? Tails is ALMOST as important as Sonic. Almost. Every hero needs a sidekick, I don't mind the idea of Sonic having a brother or sister, but the whole singing thing threw me off. At least Knuckles was in it..but I didn't get to see the episodes with Knuckles.
AoSTH: Well. The Robotnik is kind of annoying, the animation was bad. But it did focus on Sonic and Tails and their relationship which made it more like the games IMO. By the way...it had ONE element of the games: The Chaos Emeralds. Well a few actually. Grounder can be seen in Sonic 2 and so can Coconuts...though maybe not in the same incarnation. As for scratch...the closest thing to him would probably be that chicken bot manning a gun on that flying fortress zone (I think that's what it was called. The one before the Death Egg anyway and the one where they fly to the Death Egg.)
As for SatAM...I suppose the absense of Knuckles and not as much Tails action. But SatAM did have a lot of heart and soul to it, and it's darker themes made it more real. There was definately a message about environmental pollution, and freedom. It had realistic characters too.
Sonic the movie...yeah I didn't like Sera.
The owl guy was random too. It had a story...but it wasn't attached to a mainstream cartoon. No explanation for Robotnik, or anything. I think the problem with this cartoon...was that it didn't have a series behind it. It was just a story that was thrown together. No explanations for how people knew each other or anything. If there was a plot behind it, why the continents floating in the air, what happened to the surface (I'm assuming this is Earth btw. I don't think there's any mention of Mobius but I could be wrong). One of the cities reminded me of a post apocalpytic New York City. The Tails not liking lightning was cute for his character. I actually think there should've been more to it. A series perhaps. A prequel. Definately a prequel to explain everything.
Here's how I see it.
Sonic X: Too many humans. Other than that I didn't see enough of it to get a good grasp of it.
Sonic Underground: The Singing, Jaleel White doing Sonia's voice (Sonic and Manic's voice are good and all, but their sister too? O.o; ) and no Tails. What's a Sonic cartoon without Tails? Tails is ALMOST as important as Sonic. Almost. Every hero needs a sidekick, I don't mind the idea of Sonic having a brother or sister, but the whole singing thing threw me off. At least Knuckles was in it..but I didn't get to see the episodes with Knuckles.
AoSTH: Well. The Robotnik is kind of annoying, the animation was bad. But it did focus on Sonic and Tails and their relationship which made it more like the games IMO. By the way...it had ONE element of the games: The Chaos Emeralds. Well a few actually. Grounder can be seen in Sonic 2 and so can Coconuts...though maybe not in the same incarnation. As for scratch...the closest thing to him would probably be that chicken bot manning a gun on that flying fortress zone (I think that's what it was called. The one before the Death Egg anyway and the one where they fly to the Death Egg.)
As for SatAM...I suppose the absense of Knuckles and not as much Tails action. But SatAM did have a lot of heart and soul to it, and it's darker themes made it more real. There was definately a message about environmental pollution, and freedom. It had realistic characters too.
Sonic the movie...yeah I didn't like Sera.
The owl guy was random too. It had a story...but it wasn't attached to a mainstream cartoon. No explanation for Robotnik, or anything. I think the problem with this cartoon...was that it didn't have a series behind it. It was just a story that was thrown together. No explanations for how people knew each other or anything. If there was a plot behind it, why the continents floating in the air, what happened to the surface (I'm assuming this is Earth btw. I don't think there's any mention of Mobius but I could be wrong). One of the cities reminded me of a post apocalpytic New York City. The Tails not liking lightning was cute for his character. I actually think there should've been more to it. A series perhaps. A prequel. Definately a prequel to explain everything.
#38
-
- GUESTS
Posted 29 August 2008 - 05:41 AM
To me Satam is the only good Sonic cartoon! but Sonic X is the worst, I hate the way there mouths just go up and down and the episodes are just so boring and crappy. I watched the lasted episode and it sucked so bad, the doomsday project was 1000000000000000000000000 times better and that wasn't meant to be the last episode.
plus
I think why most people here like SATAM is because them things are not on it!
I would hate the show if Amy was on it, I HATE her. Robotnik is far better then eggman for this series! with out knothole.....well....I mean....there....ar...what......It would be crappy and pointless you basically hate all the things that make it SATAM! .......
My rating is...
Sonic X 10/100
AoSth 50/100
Sonic Movie 25/100
Sonic Underground 20/100
SATAM 100/100 Thats one awesome show!
plus
QUOTE ("N64fan":2f7rsm4w)
SatAm is OK, but it would be better if it had Amy, SonX Eggman,no Knothole,but the FF's still there.
My rating 4 SatAm: 87%/100
That's good enough right,?
SU=1%/100
SonX= 99%/100
OVA=20%100
AoSth=64%/100
My rating 4 SatAm: 87%/100
That's good enough right,?
SU=1%/100
SonX= 99%/100
OVA=20%100
AoSth=64%/100
I think why most people here like SATAM is because them things are not on it!
I would hate the show if Amy was on it, I HATE her. Robotnik is far better then eggman for this series! with out knothole.....well....I mean....there....ar...what......It would be crappy and pointless you basically hate all the things that make it SATAM! .......
My rating is...
Sonic X 10/100
AoSth 50/100
Sonic Movie 25/100
Sonic Underground 20/100
SATAM 100/100 Thats one awesome show!
#39
Guest_pizzapie555_*
Guest_pizzapie555_*
-
- GUESTS
Posted 08 September 2008 - 10:56 PM
dammit! i accidentally voted aosth
what i MEANT to vote for was.. well, if i had it my way, id vote for SU and SX
what i MEANT to vote for was.. well, if i had it my way, id vote for SU and SX
#40
-
- GUESTS
Posted 11 September 2008 - 12:11 PM
Sonic X sucks more ass than.... some ting that sucks a lot of ass I guess It really is a bad show and I can't see how anyone would like it. Sorry to say but I thing "4Kidz" Cartoons suck really really badly!
1 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users
