367 replies to this topic

[RedAuthar]

Fiona: Why?? She betrayed everyone

Fiona appeared as a neutral character long before betraying the group. And she was a nice person up until the Scourge replacing Sonic thing. Actually her betrayal seems rather forced. I liked her better as good guy.
Though I don't think she'd make a good couple with Tails.

I thought she was rather dull and forgettable before. As a good guy, she hardly showed any personality and was only there to make Sonic look like a player. Her character was so bleak, you could giver her any personality and it would've stuck.

While I like her better as a good guy, I don't think she has to be a nice person.

While some fans might wonder why Ken decided to pair up “Tails” and Mina, it wasn’t his decision at all. It was actually a suggestion by then-editor Justin Gabrie, one of his last inputs in the series before he was replaced by Mike Pellerito. Once again, kenpenders.com admin BobR:

The truth be told…it wasn’t Ken. When Ken and I were first discussing M:25YL pairings, we talked about who Tails might marry, and I jokingly thought “Mina” since she’s pretty cute and her speed would remind Tails of his bestest bud, Sonic. Heh! We tossed it around a bit, then nixed it for a number of reasons, not just the age difference. We were just going to have Tails alone, with no reference to any family. When Ken got the completed issue, he was rather surprised to see Tails paired with [Mina]…yes, folks, it’s a Justin Gabrie revision, since this script (and the story in #139) were turned in before Mike took over. So please don’t blame Ken on that one.

So it was random.

[Uncle Ben]

While some fans might wonder why Ken decided to pair up “Tails” and Mina, it wasn’t his decision at all. It was actually a suggestion by then-editor Justin Gabrie, one of his last inputs in the series before he was replaced by Mike Pellerito. Once again, kenpenders.com admin BobR:

The truth be told…it wasn’t Ken. When Ken and I were first discussing M:25YL pairings, we talked about who Tails might marry, and I jokingly thought “Mina” since she’s pretty cute and her speed would remind Tails of his bestest bud, Sonic. Heh! We tossed it around a bit, then nixed it for a number of reasons, not just the age difference. We were just going to have Tails alone, with no reference to any family. When Ken got the completed issue, he was rather surprised to see Tails paired with [Mina]…yes, folks, it’s a Justin Gabrie revision, since this script (and the story in #139) were turned in before Mike took over. So please don’t blame Ken on that one.

So it was random.

Makes a lot of sense now

[LaserX5]

I think Ash was made to end any chance of a MinaXSonic relationship

That's what I feel too. Not that Mina doesn't deserve someone to love, but he should have more to offer than just emotional support.

"Digital Love", eh? I'm okay with that, as long as it's nothing physical though. People are already complaining about too much Japanese influence in the comics as it is.

Yea, as long as they didn't do more than hug and kiss, I'm cool with that.

A better love candidate than randomly picking Tails from a development point of view. That's for sure.

Ok, but still... it's like Ash was only made for that purpose. That's pretty lame if you ask me.

I don't see what's wrong with Espio having feeling for Nicole when she clearly shows no attraction towards Tails.

But why would he? She's a super computer A.I, not a real Mobian. At least with Tails it would make a little bit of sense since he is a technician and uses computers. Plus, it's not entirely off the wall for Tails to possibly explore the idea of a romantic relationship with Nicole since he more than likely has given up on romance with a real female in general.

The comic does a terrible job with Chaotix...

No kidding. I really don't get why the comic doesn't use them more. They would make a great compliment to Sonic's Freedom Fighters in battle.

While I like her better as a good guy, I don't think she has to be a nice person.

I agree. She can be basically be a neutral character, even on the good side.

Not to mention her bitterness of past hurts makes her more complex.

So it was random.

That's the way it looks.

Why am I not surprised?

[Uncle Ben]

So it was random.

That's the way it looks.

Why am I not surprised?

Because some of the Arc's seem random at times.

I don't see what's wrong with Espio having feeling for Nicole when she clearly shows no attraction towards Tails.

But why would he? She's a super computer A.I, not a real Mobian. At least with Tails it would make a little bit of sense since he is a technician and uses computers. Plus, it's not entirely off the wall for Tails to possibly explore the idea of a romantic relationship with Nicole since he more than likely has given up on romance with a real female in general.

The comic does a terrible job with Chaotix...

No kidding. I really don't get why the comic doesn't use them more. They would make a great compliment to Sonic's Freedom Fighters in battle.

Tails is 11. Give him time

Chaotix would be great in battle for the Freedom Fighters

[RedAuthar]

So it was random.

That's the way it looks.

Why am I not surprised?

Because some of the Arc's seem random at times.

Cuz Penders was being lazy and didn't want to think of one

[Uncle Ben]

Because some of the Arc's seem random at times.

Cuz Penders was being lazy and didn't want to think of one

No kidding. Thats why he was terrible at times.

[Lito290]

SO HERE'S MY IDEA Khan shows up at the last minute and takes all the credit. Sally can't remember a thing and believes Khan while Sonic gets bent out of shape and starts trying to expose Khan. Sally calls him childish and they leave. Khan eventually does something stupid to drive sally back, but until then, Sonic is depressed as hell.

[RedAuthar]

That sounds like something they'd do. Doubt it thought since most Robians can remember being Robian.

[PuffinGrandeur]

They can't remember being brainwashed, but that's really the only problem that idea doesn't have.

[Uncle Ben]

Why do i think they will do that??

[PuffinGrandeur]

Because you'll believe anything negative.

[Uncle Ben]

Also they like to do this to us. I think Sonic will save the day and Khan gets rejected

[Lito290]

They will either appeal to the fans and give Khan one last middle finger as well as have no cliffhanger to the story or create another drama-filled commic giving them more options to "kill off" Khan.

[blue]

Fiona: Why?? She betrayed everyone

Fiona appeared as a neutral character long before betraying the group. And she was a nice person up until the Scourge replacing Sonic thing. Actually her betrayal seems rather forced. I liked her better as good guy.
Though I don't think she'd make a good couple with Tails.

I thought she was rather dull and forgettable before. As a good guy, she hardly showed any personality and was only there to make Sonic look like a player. Her character was so bleak, you could giver her any personality and it would've stuck.

While I like her better as a good guy, I don't think she has to be a nice person.

While some fans might wonder why Ken decided to pair up “Tails” and Mina, it wasn’t his decision at all. It was actually a suggestion by then-editor Justin Gabrie, one of his last inputs in the series before he was replaced by Mike Pellerito. Once again, kenpenders.com admin BobR:

The truth be told…it wasn’t Ken. When Ken and I were first discussing M:25YL pairings, we talked about who Tails might marry, and I jokingly thought “Mina” since she’s pretty cute and her speed would remind Tails of his bestest bud, Sonic. Heh! We tossed it around a bit, then nixed it for a number of reasons, not just the age difference. We were just going to have Tails alone, with no reference to any family. When Ken got the completed issue, he was rather surprised to see Tails paired with [Mina]…yes, folks, it’s a Justin Gabrie revision, since this script (and the story in #139) were turned in before Mike took over. So please don’t blame Ken on that one.

So it was random.

You know, the more I learn about the comic's behind the scenes the more I understand why Ken Penders quit as head writer other than being forced to work with Ian Flynn.

[LogiTeeka]

At least Ian manages to work his way through the mandates and tries continuing the story. Penders, on the other hand, quits his job then tries getting it back by taking everything with him, destroying everything in the process.

If I were him, I'd leave everything behind and start all over again. He still has that other series he's working on, so why bother?

[RedAuthar]

For Penders it's a matter of Pride.

[Uncle Ben]

Pride... isnt that one of the 7 deadly sins?

[blue]

Pride... isnt that one of the 7 deadly sins?

That depends on your viewpoints. Their nothing wrong with pride if it's used right.

[Uncle Ben]

exactly

[blue]

I just realized something, if Ian, SEGA, or the editors wanted to limit appearances of Ken Pender's characters, then why are the Tasmanian Devil Dogs are still here in the current arc? Why did I question that? Unless proven wrong, the Tasmanian Devil Dogs had first appeared in the EndGame story arc which was written by Ken Penders.